Rodgers won Super Bowl MVP honors. Rodgers, who will turn 36 in December, has 20, three less than Russell Wilson. EDITOR'S NOTE:In this excerpt from Jeff Pearlman's upcoming release,GUNSLINGER: The Remarkable, Improbable, Iconic Life of Brett Favre,the story picks up as thelegendary Packers quarterback has finished a disappointing 10-6 regular season and a Wild Card Game loss to the division-rival Minnesota Vikings. The Bills QB might have the strongest arm in the NFL, and if he keeps playing like he has through the first three weeks of the season, he could force his way into the conversation before long. What makes Favres feat all the more remarkable is the fact that he did it as quarterback. I see Utah winning because of Alex Smith, he's the one that does it. (Hint: LeBron), Best Defense Ever 80s Bears vs. 70s Steelers, 2022 NFL Season Predictions w/NFL on Fox Mark Schlereth. Favre for his crazy longevity, Rodgers for his crazy efficiency, both for their physical talent . Its who has the better arm. Develop first-step quickness, serve with power and add inches to your vertical with volleyball training from some of todays top coaches. 10. I really dont know what to expect., Tomlinson felt pangs of sympathy for the kid. Rodgers scored a 1310 on the SATs and graduated Pleasant Valley High with an A- average. Brett Favre. The one area holding back Stafford is his lack of throws off-schedule, on the move and outside the pocket. This was not well received, and rightly believed to be more about draft status than readiness. Or perennial all Pro FB Tony Richardson, or LB Calvin Pace or DT Kris Jenkins or had a top five draft pick (LB Vernon Gholston). Harlan was, however, never comfortable with such a consolidation of power, and grew increasingly concerned as Sherman blew high draft picks on busts and floundered in drawing free agents. Career Stats for QB Aaron Rodgers. Then, Patrick Mahomes came along. Now shut the fuck up., Rodgers listened to Driverfor all of four seconds. He has lost a combined 180 yards while being the victim of a QB sack 30 times. Yes, I know efficiency isnt sexy but was the size if Bretts Big Arm worthit? The Packers beat the Panthers the following season and won 23-10 on the road at San Francisco on Jan. 11, 1998. Rodgers became the fifth quarterback since the NFL-AFL merger to make five conference championship appearances. The experience is about as ridiculous as you probably remember. Rodgers was now. To hear Rodgers tell it, his right arm itself isnt actually all that important. Rodgers told me last year that the hardest pass of his career came on a TD pass to Jordy Nelson in the 2010 divisional round against Atlanta on a throw moving to his left. All rights reserved. 24, the Packers were likely to pounce. There was also the matter of finances. Get it together, Broncos fans. Before the 2005 NFL Draft (where the Packers selected Rodgers with the 24th overall pick), one anonymous NFC scout told the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel that Tedford-tutored quarterbacks were too well-schooled. It was too much. So now Thompson was the GM, Sherman back to serving merely as the head coach. Packers: Aaron Rodgers praises Jordan Love. 1 overall, nobody was particularly shocked. Elway, and by a mile high. While playing in Green Bay, Aaron Rodgers, where the temperature was almost freezing . (Photo of Brett Favre: Brian Bahr /Allsport via Getty Images). After a few seasons, he's now become the game's best QB. That opportunity comes with a matchup againsttheTampa BayBuccaneersat 3:05 p.m. on Sunday. NFL insider has surprising update on Aaron Rodgers' future. brett favre and aaron rodgers are two of the most recognized figures in the history of the green bay packers. He was smart and studious, and it all went over like a bowl of maggot-coated Fruit Loops. GUNSLINGER: The Remarkable, Improbable, Iconic Life of Brett Favre. Favre won the award three consecutive years from 1995-97. Excluding their 51-29 drubbing at the hands of the Saints, theyve lost theirlast six games by a total of 18 points, losing all six in the fourth quarter. Rodgers is the better QB. Green Bay Packers fans have undoubtedly been spoiled for the last 27 years as Aaron Rodgers took over once Brett Favre departed. Favre and Rodgers are two of the eight NFL players with multiple NFL MVP awards. You have to fight. Rodgers entered the game late and struggled. Follow the new B/R Mag stream onthe Team Stream appand #BRmag onFacebook,InstagramandTwitterfor sports storytelling worth your time, wherever you are. No QB Rodgers included has routinely produced more highlights per play during his first few seasons as a starter. I looked it up. Favre threw for 11 TDs in his last season compared to 19 picks and his longest pass of the year went for 53 yards. Rodgers has a more cool, calm demeanor, but isn't necessarily the biggest leader on his own team. Other than Mahomes, no other quarterback in the NFL does a better job of changing his arm angle to pull off crazy throws in the pocket. I think no. Anthony Fasano? 12 dealt with a far different approach from previous signal-caller Brett Favre. Favre could put so much velocity behind those balls that the loft typically needed was no longer important. It bothered me. During his streak, 238 other quarterbacks started in the NFL including 17 who were backups to Favre at one point in their careers. Rodgers grabbed a pen and, without knowing, scribbled Aaron Rodgers in black Sharpie on his own helmet. Not who can throw the ball through a receivers chest. Training refers to the workouts, exercises and drills they perform outside of organized practices to improve their Strength, Speed, Conditioning and Flexibility, as well to rehab and prevent injury. Hes a fire-breathing dragon who happens to play quarterback. If you watch that throw, youll see how Rodgers almost uses his left leg as a peg to stop his momentum rather than taking a long step to add velocity. He read defenses like a 12-year veteran and stayed in the pocket without cowering. Aaron Rodgers needs three TD tosses Sunday against the Ravens to tie Brett Favre's franchise career record of 442 and . About three or four days before the draft, he said, I was convinced that the best thing to do, if he got to us, was draft Aaron Rodgers. Finally, approximately five hours after Smith went No. Heled the Packers to a pair of Super Bowl appearances. Favre's bid for a repeat in Super Bowl XXXII fell short in a 31-24 loss to Denver. For even more softball training, check out softball video library. He hated how the teams notoriously protective PR staff served as his personal brick wall, and laughed as rival journalists left offerings at the shrine of Brett. Lets just compare the raw data of 2009 as it stands, independent of any emotional response: Rodgers GREEN BAY, WISCONSIN - SEPTEMBER 15: Aaron Rodgers #12 of the Green Bay Packers shares a moment with former quarterback Brett Favre during a ceremony for the late Bart Starr at halftime of the . But Im chasing a little more nuance than that. Favre offered little (well, no) advice, but the kid wasnt exactly seeking out the information. But alas, the stars have aligned in the most Shakespearian of ways withthe Gunslinger taking on Noodle Arm this weekend with a playoff birthon the line. Although he never won a Super Bowl, his powerful arm deserves recognition. Maybe the strongest . While you can see that Rodgers won four of the six rounds, one might argue that the varying importance of each category makes it a lot different, as a player can win games pretty much on intangibles alone (see: Tebow, Tim). I really do.. Its not the most thrilling play from the Mahomes library, but it might be one of the most notable. This is an oft-debated topic and people sometimes forget just how dominant Favre was in his prime. With all that in mind, lets breeze through some candidates who just missed the cut. Favre was liable to do anything. He was jumping on the heels of the guy in front of him, said Ben Steele, a Packer tight end. Eventually, Rodgers became comfortable holding the ball between the middle of his chest and his throwing shoulder. As part of this process, I surveyed a few football buffs that I trust, and multiple people immediately brought up Jeff George. One day in a quarterbacks meeting he said, Brett, what did you get on it?, I do, Rodgers said. You know, he said, I dont think you can ever replace a legend.. With so much speculation on the possibility of Rodgers following Brett Favre's footsteps to the Jets, Rodgers could go full Favre one other way. You know, thatone guy who leads the entire NFL in passing TD while maintaining anearly 3 to 1 TD to INT ratio? While it is no secret that Favre had an absolute cannon, Rodgers has a rocket of an arm himself. Rodgers has surpassed that mark in four separate seasons. Possibly. Both QBs possess the ability to zip balls into tight windows and also complete the long . A former linebacker with the Houston Oilers in the late-1970s and early 80s, Thompson was a humorless man who had spent five seasons as Seattles vice president of operations and, before that, six years in Green Bay heading the pro personnel department. Green Bay has the 24th overall pick in the upcoming NFL Draft, but Favre isn't quite ready to welcome their first-round selection, a quarterback from Cal, to the team. On the HBO series Inside the NFL, analyst Cris Collinsworth, one of the games most respected voices, said, If this Packer team is sitting there at 2-8, the last six games absolutely have to go to Aaron Rodgers., Favres play was inconsistent. That 22nd win over Chicago for Rodgers tied him in Packers history with Brett Favre, who went 22-10 against the Bears from 1992-2007. But Rodgers was confident and cool and somewhat tone deaf. Please see our Contributors and Sources page for data source details. Favre led the Packers to their first Super Bowl victory in 30 years, and he remains one of the franchise's most-beloved players despite the two-year stint with the rival Vikings. John Elway: Throwing up to 70 yards down the field right on the money says a lot about the strength of Elway's arm. Copyright 2023 Sporting News Holdings Limited. Which Player Does NBA Twitter Hate The Most? Terry Bradshaw: In his day, the Steelers quarterback made some perfectly prolific deep balls that left fans gasping. While Favres INT to TD ratio is almost 1 to 1, Rodgers is one TD shy of 2 to 1 and hes thrown 25 more passes. Favre finished 25 of 42 for 256 yards, three TDs and an interception in the loss. I'll start off with a common attribute that is frequently looked for when scouting quarterbacks: arm strength. Favre said he felt the pressure mounting once Rodgers joined the team and threatened his job. Hes not even good. Which was laughablehe was real good.), but the younger players felt his sense of urgency, and responded. The SPORTS REFERENCE and STATHEAD trademarks are owned exclusively by Sports Reference LLC. Brett Favre has lived this. Favre has twice as many. From New Englands 1-yard line, Mahomes took a shotgun snap, drifted to his left, and dropped a rainbow to Hill in the back corner of the end zone. No one went out after games. Arrive a bit late for a meeting? The goal here is to figure out who has the best all-around arm talent. Brett Favre threw 442 career touchdown passes as a Packers. But after watching hundreds of combined throws from about a dozen different QBs, this really did come down to a three-man race. Tedford had a history of coaching quarterbacks who put up eye-popping numbers in college yet fizzled out in the NFL. A Fantasy Football Love Affair, Jerome Bettis On Running Over Brian Urlacher, Being Fantasy Goalline Vulture, The Greatest Tecmo Super Bowl Story Ever Told Big Red, LeBron vs Jordan = Whos The GOAT? Its a picture-perfect study on how to use your entire body to create power. In some situations, athletes gain an edge with prescribed use of safe supplements. Their relationship aside, on the field as of this moment with Rodgers still playing and his legacy incomplete, which one is better Brett Favre or Aaron Rodgers? Rodgers' mechanics left a lot to be desired . Every NFL fan tends to go bonkers about QB stats and each athletes place in history. His consecutive starts streak of 297 is a testament to that, and he's the toughest QB ever to play the game, both physically and mentally. Whether it be a 75 yard l. Favres career highlights include two Super Bowl appearances including a victory over the New England Patriots in 1996, a three-time league MVP (1995, 1996, 1997), three All-Pro honors, and 11 Pro Bowls. Aaron Rodgers vs. Brett Favre: Inside the almost identical playoff legacies for Packers QBs. Jim Hart: Hart completed a record of 98 yards passing in the air, as his throws seemed to leave a vapor trail.. The morning after the news, Nall arrived at the facility with a copy of an image someone had e-mailed him, featuring a person in a shirt reading ALL DADDY WANTED WAS A BLOW JOB. All logos are the trademark & property of their owners and not Sports Reference LLC. In the football world, many of the loudest and longest-running points of contention understandably concern QBs. Scoring statistics (TD, XP, FG) are complete all-time. Brett Favreled Green Bay to the NFC championship in a 30-13 victory against Carolina on Jan. 12, 1997. To me. No doubt the main reason for the Green Bay Packers ' success the past 25 years has been Hall of Fame quarterback play with three-time MVP Brett Favre and two-time MVP Aaron Rodgers. Rodgers just threw the ball. No QB during that stretch has been better at making a football do precisely what he wants it to. In hindsight, much of it had to do with a cold-footed reaction to negative scouting reports. Three running backs, three wide receivers and three cornerbacks rounded out the Top 10. Rodgers is officially back, and his revenge tour has included the sorts of absurd throws that have always set him apart. As Favre's popularity decreased in Wisconsin, his replacement, Aaron Rodgers, gained approval at a similar pace. Favres wild energy and frenetic style make it seem like hes making more difficult throws, but Rodgers shouldnt get dinged for making the impossible look easy. No QB in the history of football has been able to harness that power quite like Rodgers. 15 3730 63.4 25 13 91.4, Favre Find out more. Hart was one of the first registered cannons the NFL ever saw. Rodgers is tough. It bothered a lot of us., Sean McHugh, a Packers tight end, said Rodgers was a nice kid with, California swag. Which wasnt the same as Mississippi or Green Bay swag. Does that make him better than Favre? Favre holds that record at the 1 spot. He read defenses like a 12-year veteran and stayed in the pocket without cowering. Jack Kemp: With various types of passing records in the AFL record books, there is no disputing the arm strength of Kemp. As mentioned earlier, he's patient and doesn't normally try to force the ball into coverage unless absolutely necessary. Aaron Rodgers, 2005-present When people compare Favre and Rodgers (who've somehow held down the Packers ' starting QB job for the past 28 years ), I think it's easy to get distracted by how . Arizonas starting quarterback was the forgettable Josh McCownand they selected a cornerback, Miamis Antrel Rolle, eighth. The problem, however, was that they were tough to find. Fine. Im not looking at you. He was a jerk. (Brett) Favre in the 2009 Monday Night Football game and how electric that was. Back in 1991 he lasted into the fifth round before being picked by San Francisco. Smith and Rodgers were widely considered a coin flip. If we put someones real helmet out there. The next morning Rodgers arrived at the facility and could not locate his helmet. The first Super Bowl that I can remember was 49ers-Chargers in early 1995, and the first time I saw Favre play live was on a miserable Halloween night at Soldier Field a few months earlier. Our reasoning for presenting offensive logos. Rodgers was Favres equal when it came to arm strength, and he was already, as a rookie, a far better decision maker. Once, when Mark Brunell rose from the bench in 1994, there was a (relatively slim) possibility of Favre being replaced. Brett Favre was the starting quarterback for the Green Bay Packers when the team drafted up and coming sensation Rodgers back in 2005. At age 36, Rodgers is currently third in the NFL in total passing EPA, and the Packers rank second in Football Outsiders offensive DVOA. We eliminated the years when Aaron Rodgers was substituted for Brett Favre in 2017 or when Tom Brady was substituted and suffered a knee injury. Youre smart. Mahomes is, undeniably, the most spectacular passer in the NFL. One day, weeks before the draft, Cortez called Rossley and begged him to come and watch Rodgers throw. He was devastated. Others, like OBrien and Couch, arrived and departed with barely a shadow. Those two quarterbacks have combined for almost 30 years of success in Green Bay with Hall of Fame-caliber quarterback play, and the comparisons will continue long after Rodgers ultimately retires. broadcast or podcast, please strongly consider citing this site as the Aaron Rodgers currently has 171 career touchdown passes. Aaron Rodgers sports the best touchdown-to-interception ratio in NFL history as well as the highest career passer rating with 104.93, which is a whole eight points ahead of second place. In a humiliating 21-14 loss at Cincinnati on Oct. 30, Favre was intercepted five times. Barroom arguments are the lifeblood of sports fandom. He was laid-back and casual and happy to show the reporter around his home. If you ever see any of the old quarterback competitions that ABC used to put on over in Hawaii in the off-season, Favre once won the long throw event with a . Over the years, everything quieted. Thats only possible because Rodgers is consistently able to reset himself often while in motion and get his left shoulder pointed in the direction that hes throwing. Hes also thrown 368 consecutive passes without being picked off, which is a new NFL record. Favre eyed it, turned to Nall and said, You know what would be funny? Then on November 29, 200710 years ago WednesdayRodgers got his chance to give Favre a push. Favre's six TD game versus the Cardinals is the . John Elway: Throwing up to 70 yards down the field right on the money says a lot about the strength of Elways arm.